Generation tug of war

Which starlet who never quite made it huge was/is hottest? Yesterday's Jennifer Jason Leigh or today's Christina Ricci?

I was having a fantasy about once child stars now kinky and twenty somethings and Miss Ricci came to mind. Then was I thinking of Jennifer Jason Leigh a few years past Fast Times at Ridgemont High and thought I would feel I like I was cheating on her. Who would you choose?